The Human Rights Law Centre has launched a legal challenge on behalf of Susan Neill-Fraser against a new parole condition that prevents her from publicly claiming her innocence.
The case, being heard in the Supreme Court of Tasmania, was adjourned until 10 September 2025.
Media release – Human Rights Law Centre, 13 August 2025
Legal challenge against Tasmanian parole board’s new gag order against Susan Neill-Fraser
The Human Rights Law Centre has brought further legal proceedings on behalf of Tasmanian grandmother, Susan Neill-Fraser, to challenge a new restrictive parole condition which seeks to prevent her from speaking to any third parties, including the media, to claim her alleged innocence or wrongful conviction.
This new parole condition replaces and expands an old parole condition which prevented her from speaking to the media.
The case, which is being heard in the Supreme Court of Tasmania, was adjourned today until 10 September. It argues that the new condition is unreasonable, improper and in breach of the constitutionally implied freedom of political communication.
Sarah Schwartz, Legal Director at the Human Rights Law Centre said:
“Freedom of speech and political communication are core democratic rights that belong to everyone – including and especially people who have been in prison, whose voices are essential to a just and democratic society.
“Parole should be a pathway to reintegration, not a way of continuing to impose punishment.
“When parole conditions silence people or limit their freedom of expression, they violate basic human rights and increase the risk of re-incarceration.”
“Instead of stopping people from speaking out after being in prison, parole should be focused on ensuring people are supported as they re-enter the community,” said Schwartz.
Background
Susan Neill-Fraser served 13 years in prison and has been on parole since 2022.
In December 2024, the Tasmanian Parole Board placed a condition on Susan’s parole which prohibited her from communicating “directly or indirectly with any media outlet to claim [her] alleged innocence and/or wrongful conviction”.
In May 2025, this condition was replaced with a condition which prohibits her from communicating “directly or indirectly – including through third parties, written statements, electronic communications, social media platforms, television, radio, podcasts, streaming services, online video-sharing platforms, or any other public or broadcast media – to assert claims regarding your alleged innocence, wrongful conviction, or dispute the legitimacy of your conviction or sentencing”.
Tasmanian Times (TT) is a community-based news and current affairs service covering the island state of Tasmania. It exists to provide a diverse view of Tasmanian issues. TT creates and supports independent media content utilising the best of modern technologies and tried-and-true practices of public-interest journalism.
Support us in expanding our coverage and developing new content by and for Tasmanians.
New initiatives on the way include:
- a weekly podcast covering current affairs
- a revamped website
- a monthly cartoon competition
- a user-friendly app for both Android and Apple devices
- a weekly roundup of key stories
