Since arriving in Tasmania eleven years ago, I have become aware of many existing, and witnessed a plethora of new Government backed projects.
Each and every one has proven to be a complete and utter failure and a financial disaster. It seems that they have invented the Sadim touch. It is the opposite of Midas, and everything touched turns to crap.
I cannot think of one single project that has lived up to the hype and the expectations, and for each and every one of them they have opened the Treasury doors and poured the contents into the waste bin.
Here are just a few pearls in the very long string.
Hydro – billed as the saviour for Tasmania. Abundant cheap electricity was the sales pitch. Ha ha! This was then coupled to –
Bass Link – a one-way stream of money out of the country costing a $100 million a year – and again to –
Bell Bay Power Station – bought and then converted to gas. Followed by the building of an identical gas-powered station next door, all of which has cost us a fortune and is barely used.
Spirit of Tasmania III – supposed to bring a bounty of tourists to these fair shores. They sold it a year later after making a loss and lost a further $10 million on the sale price.
Broadband Network – something that will turn Tasmania into the business capital of Australia – if only they can get anyone to use it.
Meander Valley Dam – designed to boost food crops in the Meander area – only the farmers didn’t want it and now the land has largely been turned over to plantations. $30 million down the drain there.
The RFA – Possibly the less said the better. This has brought about the destruction of the forests, has been a killer for the tourist industry and turned Forestry Tasmania into an insatiable money guzzler, unable to return a profit in over ten years.
Then the Mersey Hospital fiasco – which is still ongoing despite several attemps at resuscitation. This was followed by the –
Launceston General Hospital and a multitude of mismanagement and costs, but both these were outstripped by the
Hobart Waterfront Hospital – which has absorbed millions in planning costs without a single brick being laid, and now abandoned for an upgrade to the existing building running into further millions.
Football sponsorship – another costly error. A couple of return matches in Launceston were supposed to bring the tourists flocking here in their thousands, but they forgot in their calculations that there is no adequate transport to get them here.
The Midlands Foodbowl – A Bartlett wet dream for the driest part of the island and expensive irrigation systems being put in when the North-West, which is the real foodbowl, is struggling, with companies like Simplot pulling out and going to New Zealand.
Then who stopped the wood supply to Scottsdale and forced the largest closure in the timber industry? None other than our own GBE, Forestry!
Now we have $12.5 Million spent on another racetrack without going through any due process and without a profit plan. But then, that is small change from what was given to –
Federal Hotels – who got a monopolistic gaming right worth a few hundred millions for a mere three, and were supposed to build a very large hotel in the Freycinet National Park in part exchange for this generosity, but failed to meet the promise.
And who bought an airport at an inflated price way above anything it could ever return to the taxpayer and sold water and sewage rights to private corporations with immediate price rises for the consumers?
Then there was that other lovely piece of legislation involving Planning with the PAL Policy disfranchising about 30 000 Tasmanian citizens and depriving them of their basic Common Law rights to own and develop their property, just so that the MIS conspirators could collar their land and turn it into a disastrous Ponzi get-rich-quick plantation scheme using Federal largess and tax avoidance.
Then we have a Fox eradication farce that destroys imaginary foxes at a cost of over a million dollars each, and this has been chasing its tail for the last ten years.
And of course, the BIG one. The Pulp Mill Assessment Act that assessed absolutely nothing before fast-tracking it through parliament and opening the State coffers for a private, largely mainland-based company and spruiking it at public expense to this very day. Meanwhile writing specialised laws at their behest and gifting them things like culverts and new roads and infrastructure and compulsory purchasing them an access right over private land for their pipeline. As part of the deal they also get massive water supplies at miniscule rates, and they even went as far as building special dams to ensure their supply. If that wasn’t enough, they then gave them a FREE 20 year access right to all Tasmania’s forests, and when they discovered, that with all these free gifts, they still could not be commercially viable, they offer to buy back this free gift for possibly $200 Million. They did not consider that by NOT using it, Forestry and the people of Tasmania LOST $200 million and the non-fulfilment of the contract clause was waived without a cent changing hands!
And now this whole thing is being set up so that history can repeat itself with the financial backing of a new kid on the block called Aprin. Lots of chutzpah. They have managed to procure about three million in ‘start-up’ grants, retooling grants and now a loan to buy a dilapidated chip mill. And Forestry has apparently already signed a wood supply agreement with them despite the ongoing ‘Forest Agreement’ negotiations, and all before they actually got their finance for the chip mill purchase. Can anybody else see why there is such desperation to tread the same rocky path again?
Meanwhile, we are having trouble with our prisons – possibly because they contain the wrong group of people – our nurses, doctors and hospital services are under financial pressure, our most successful schools are being closed and they are cutting back on police numbers.
Unless I have overlooked something, on the positive side there is – NOTHING!
Except possibly, that the force of 30,000 bureaucrats, who are largely responsible for advising the government, are having their own numbers pared back by 1700. I would suggest that this is probably far too little far too late and with leaders and advisors like we have – the Titanic looks a safe bet.
Rob Walls
July 2, 2011 at 13:59
Barnaby, you can also add all sorts of “Intelligent Island” projects…funny, that phrase is not heard much these days. Yep, an island. Intelligent? Perhaps there was just insufficient evidence.
You could also add the Mount Wellington cable car to your list. I don’t think there has ever been an accurate tally of funding spent on the “development” of that little venture.
mike seabrook
July 2, 2011 at 14:07
and when it is time to replenish the treasury & when wilkie & the greens cannot extort the feds to hand down more of the loot from the qld coal miners & the wa iron ore miners to these lab-green wastrels in tasmania – look out
those with jobs in tasmania or assets in tasmania should look out for when the taxes, charges & other hits really start coming.
hydro charges, tobacco taxes, alcohol taxes,water charges, sewerage charges, petrol charges, motor registration & road charges, land taxes, municipal rate levy hits, car parking charges & limitations of street parking,charges for publically owned houses & buildings increasing, greenhouse taxes, carbon taxes, & then higher interest rates & a higher exchange rate for all which will really pressure tas manufacturing & agriculture & fishing resources.
– at least house prices in tasmania should become much more affordable for tasmanians (& mainlanders & foreigners) who have jobs.
the protected species of big stinkers & pokies & circuses to amuse will likely continue under the protection of these tassie lab-greens.
it is a free world – disinvest & reduce exposure to likely hits & consider migrating (at least in the long cold tassie winter) as a boat person from tasmania or purge these lab-greens.
how goes the taj mahal masoleum which these wastrels have contracted to occupy behind parliament house in hobart.
John Biggs
July 2, 2011 at 14:39
Try this URL on TT:
http://oldtt.pixelkey.biz/index.php?/search/results/cbaf732504a104108a2bbf47cd66cb27/
and at the bottom “the ten worst decisions” with over 100 suggestions.
How can so few get so much so wrong?
AnnoyingOrange
July 2, 2011 at 14:44
Given this ongoing ripping off of the public purse, in the context of the recent school closures, I am surprised Tasmanians are not now tearing down the state parliament building.
How does the big end of town get away with it?
The school closures will kill rural communities, starting with rural real estate prices. As a mainlander, we put a bid on a property in Meander because it had a school. Now there is no way we would buy property there, or any of these other places with no schools. The big end of town is destroying the little people’s home values to pay for their own bankrupting policies. It takes your breath away just thinking about it.
While the big schemes may “fail”, the big end of town still gets big money out of it. The CEOs still earn squillions regardless of success or failure. And Tasmanians put up with it.
Tasmania needs a new political party that has a whole new way of doing things. The time is right, while people are angry. I assume a great many Tasmanians are angry … or don’t they care? Is it just a handful on TT who are angry?
*PS – How the hell can the state government refuse to sell to someone that lobs with cash (at Triabunna) only to refuse the offer and sell to someone else who needs a government-subsidised loan? Once again, it takes your breath away. No market forces at play – there is only one way, the big end of town’s way.
John Biggs
July 2, 2011 at 15:37
I’ve been thinking about my last question. One explanation is that we have been consistently electing singularly stupid politcians ove the past ten years, which is as unkind as it is unlikely. More plausible is that there is a systemic problem, which surely dates back in part to the decision to reduce the size of both houses. Too few ministers have had to handle more portfolios than they reasonably can. So they appoint minders who give them the sort of advice that will keep them, the minders, in their jobs, but those minders aren’t subject to the checks and balances that an independent public service is subject to. Consequently when things go wrong, the pressure is to cover up rather than to put things right.
Coupled with this is when the Labor party followed the Hawke-Keating line into economic rationalism, thus closing the gap between the two major parties and thereby losing their traditional constituency, the genuine battlers and underprivileged, in order to serve the corporate world. That then laid them open to accepting donations, sucking up to the corporate world, and thus to Gunns and Forestry practices that suited short term gains for the few — which had once been Liberal turf. With little differences between the parties, politics became a policy-free and personality and poll driven operation about who is to be in power (as the Gillard-Abbott disgrace shows all too clearly) not about good governance.
Things are made even worse, as Peter Henning pointed out here a couple of years ago, with caucus driven politics; too few are making bad decisions on bad advice but all are forced to agree whatever their private reservations. So the whole bloody system is structured to give bad governance, in which good people become enmired. This is what I think has happened to the Greens in power sharing.
Today’s Australian quotes Bob Brown as saying that the Greens will become the major party at the expense of the ALP. If so, that might be a step towards policy driven politics, but they will have to be careful. Parallels with the Democrats, who in their time were in the ascendant and held the balance of power in the Senate, are a warning about getting too close to a major party.
Simon Warriner’s suggestions http://oldtt.pixelkey.biz/index.php?/article/a-way-forward-for-tasmanian-politics/
presents a much-needed way to go.
Anyway Barnaby I want to thank you for your article, which was a well-researched and timely reminder of where we are at present and where we have been. And thanks for the Sadim Touch: great, except that unlike Midas who was an individual the Sadim touch is not I think about individuals about about a whole cocked up system.
salamander
July 2, 2011 at 16:17
I would call it the LibLab way. They have their mates, their special interests, and that is how it has been run for far too long. Just think of the waterfront, to be decorated with a private excrescence to remove that less desirable ferry pier. Did any Liberals object when that was discussed in parliament? Of course not, they were maaates! Was there any stakeholder consultation, or public announcement? No, that’s not the way our state government works.
Sneaky deals, sleight of hand, no proper planning, like special legislation to “sell” Zero Davey for $1, the development of IXL Jam Factory by Henry Jones that was not to be visible above the facade but is, giving away the Transport Dept building for $100,000, these are the way it is done in Tassie.
But until more of the moribund voters stop blaming “foreigners” from interstate for everything and start to care about the place they call home, it won’t change.
john hayward
July 2, 2011 at 21:37
Barnaby is only seeing things from the public perspective, rather than that of those “representing” us.
Some of the above are probably just stuff-ups of the sort suffered by amateurs everywhere, but most have probably seen at least one or two of our representatives hit a jackpot.
John Hayward
William Boeder
July 2, 2011 at 23:04
Thank you Barnaby Drake for your compilation of all that the State Lib/Lab ministers, the State government aligned bureaucrats, the battalion of minders and nodders, and those reprehensible stinko’s of Tasmania Incorporated, have imparted upon our Tasmania.
This article you have presented here is jam-packed with the truth.
However, soon it will be hosed down by this government and their media mates, (and or deftly ignored,) in some manner or form, loudly decrying and denying all these truths, as just little aberrations that pop-up from time to time and happens everywhere?
I note the present absence of the pro-logging clan and those on the government take whom have not yet leapt upon this factual account of fiscal failures, to howl down the truths that you Barnaby, have now thrust out into the public arena?
The sheer totality of the floppos and failures is a timely telling testament to the many articles and comments that have poured forth into the Tasmanian Times for some number of years.
Any wonder the likes of Thuggo Lennon and of the other stoats, including the Davids And Michael’s that in the past would not accept even the existence of Tas Times, let alone the citizen’s views to the arrogant slipshod chaos of our State government’s improper conducts.
The frequency of their deals for mates and robbing the citizens in order to enhance the fortunes of the now grossly reviled plundering private company of Gunns Ltd?
Let us not forget that principle stinker of a ministerr whom allowed the rampant use of such an array of toxic and health-destroying bastard chemicals to be unleashed upon Tassie’s clean green environments?
To think that some of the past anti-the-people ex pollies are now warmly accepted as lobbyists, still keenly seeking to enter to this rotted festering government of their own creation?
This matter should become a National issue of shame upon all those fidelity busting bastards who oversaw and allowed such ruin and showers of chemical rain to smack upon the people and the State of Tasmania?
A great piece of honest work here Barnaby!