Tasmanian Times

The individual has always had to struggle to keep from being overwhelmed by the tribe. If you try it, you will be lonely often, and sometimes frightened. No price is too high for the privilege of owning yourself. ~ Friedrich Nietzsche

The individual has always had to struggle to keep from being overwhelmed by the tribe. If you try it, you will be lonely often, and sometimes frightened. No price is too high for the privilege of owning yourself. ~ Friedrich Nietzsche


NATION: “We were robbed … “

“We were robbed.” Labor’s lies about Medicare blinded voters to the allure of tax cuts for the rich and funding cuts to hospitals and schools. In Tasmania, the Prime Minister tells the three amigos, Eric Hutchinson, Andrew Nikolic and Brett Whiteley what they want to hear. He’s good at that – and he’s not bad at finger-pointing either. Everything is Labor’s fault again this week from Hazelwood’s closure to South Australia’s aggressive 40% renewable energy target by 2020 which he is hoping we forget was set by the Howard government.

It’s just what the reality evaders and Tony Abbott supporters need to hear. It’s not that they were bad advocates for those who elected them. It’s not that their policies were few and fanciful. It’s that someone else is to blame. It’s a Turnbull government mantra; a futile bid to evade accountability. Don’t expect Nikolic to ask the PM to help him honour his tertiary education funding campaign promise of $150 million to UTAS for a new campus at Inveresk.

Turnbull has been stood up by Joko Widodo whose immense personal popularity has led more than one reporter to ponder whether our PM has something to learn from him. They have much in common. For starters, Joko Widodo is just another puppet of predatory oligarchic elites. Naturally, fluffy puff pieces are being rushed to our screens now in which Jokowi, as he is known, explains his amazing strategy of talking to the people.

Yet suddenly, unfathomably, the man of the people has a riot to attend to; a popular protest where some in the mob seem out for his blood. Some days, as One Nation bush poet Rod Culleton says, dog-shit just sticks to your boot.

Is there an Indonesian solution in the pipeline? Certainly, the problem of what to do with asylum-seekers on Manus and Nauru won’t go away just because we can’t talk about it. Whatever was in the wind, Joko’s choking has meant Turnbull is robbed by fate once again of a chance to pose as a statesman. Now, as Liberal shill Nikki Savva puts it on ABC Insiders Sunday he must go (once again) into “a new week of parliament with nothing”.

Fate also snatches away any chance to chat about the Ubud Writers’ festival where a year ago Jokowi made news for censoring three panel discussions set up to explore the Indonesian genocide of 1965; the brutal repression of the will of the people in which it is estimated up to a million people were executed for being suspected of opposing the government; communists, left-wingers, critics, independent thinkers and suchlike.

… all complicit in the crimes …

Secrecy makes it impossible to know how many died, but our PM will surely want to chat with Widodo about the international panel of judges which concluded this July that Indonesia’s mass killings of 1965 were crimes against humanity, and that the United States, United Kingdom and Australia were all complicit in the crimes.

Luckily for all concerned, an epic extravaganza bursts upon the national stage this week sweeping all before it. Holy smoke! Hazelwood mania is taking the country by storm.

The arresting tale of an elderly coal-fired power station in intensive care battling to come to terms with its mortality seizes the imagination of the nation, Hazelwood Mon Amor is an extraordinary production in which virtuous denim-clad artisan turbine tenders in moccasins and tats heroically contend with impending disaster caused when perfidious socialists collude with greenies to close the noble smokestacks of a poor community’s life support system.

Hazelwood, we are told, will lose up to a 1000 jobs – all because of a state Labor government’s avarice in tripling its brown coal royalty and its demonic pursuit of a 40% renewable energy target for green-washed ideological reasons. And it gets worse. Hazelwood’s closure will cripple a vibrant LaTrobe Valley economy. Without Hazelwood, the state will go from a net energy exporter to a net importer. Next thing you know, Victoria will be forced to suck on the withered tit of Basslink. It’s the last blow for coal, we are told, as if that’s a bad thing.

Hazelwood is a post-truth drama. The Andrews government’s new royalty merely brings Victoria into line with NSW; its 40% renewables by 2025 target sees it join ACT, Queensland and South Australia, states with more ambitious targets than the federal government which has cut its target causing a three year drought in investment. And Victoria’s target will create employment. Victoria’s Minister for Energy and Climate, Lily D’Ambrosio says her state’s scheme is expected to generate 3000 jobs by 2020, before any costs were imposed, and then another 4000 additional jobs by 2023/24.

Yet the government of the turning bull never lets fact spoil its story. The loss of 1000 jobs is tiny compared with an SEC workforce slashed from 11,000 in the late 1980s to 2600 in Jeff Kennett’s newly privatised state power grid which left one third of families in Moe and Morwell without breadwinners. Nor are the workers merely cast aside penniless. The CFMEU, demonised by the Coalition, has negotiated $300,000 plus redundancy packages for workers. The confected outrage has nothing to do with compassion for the workers or their families.

The Hazelwood saga is scripted by Peabody Energy, the world’s largest coal-mining company in which the closure of mines and power stations is reduced to a choice between jobs or coal. The environment can fend for itself; what really matters is “energy security” another Peabody concept, that only coal or gas-fired generation can bestow and something archly referred to as baseload power which cannot possibly be achieved without baseload generators burning coal or perhaps powered by nuclear reactors.

… a fight between the past and the future …

Yet north German states Mecklenburg-Vorpommern and Schleswig-Holstein already operate on 100% net renewable energy, mostly wind; trading with each other and neighbours and without baseload power stations.

As Christine Milne put it “‘We are now in the midst of a fight between the past and the future.’ The refutation of the baseload fairy tale and other myths falsely denigrating renewable energy are a key part of that struggle.”

Once again a tamed ABC and a bought mainstream commercial media do big mining’s dirty work for it on behalf of a crisis-ridden, coal-powered Coalition desperately in need of a tactical diversion if not aerial support in its jihad against renewables, refugees, reporters or anyone who might tell truth to power.

Our ABC blitzes the airwaves, sensationalising the long overdue closure of brown coal-burning Hazelwood, the dirtiest power station in the developed world, a dinosaur of energy generation. Josh Frydenberg lies that the Andrews government has driven the operator out of town while French owner Engie repeatedly explains that its decision to close the 50 year old plant is economic; nothing to do with state government policies.

Aunty’s obsession almost eclipses the chaos in the Senate as Liberal stooge Bob Day, who even managed to vote to cut family allowances, resigns as the High Court prepares to get the last laugh on One Nation’s Rob Culleton, an amateur stand-up comedian who claims “four glasses of wine” may have caused him to incorrectly declare he was eligible to stand for the Senate.

Culleton also believes that the High Court has been acting illegally in not issuing writs in the name of the Queen but that will not prevent it sitting in judgment on his eligibility to be a senator given that he was a convicted felon at the time he stood for office, a conviction that was subsequently quashed. What may not help Culleton defend his false declaration is his apparent insolvency, broadly defined as owing more money than you can pay back.

The One Nation funster appears to have a liquidity crisis, owing around $5 million to Wesfarmers and a bank. But there’s no justice, as Rod himself is fond of pointing out. Don’t get him started on the Family Court.

Being insolvent did not preclude Bob Day from voting nine out of 10 times with the government when technically his financial interest in his own North Adelaide electoral office building may also have made him ineligible to stand for the senate. The High Court will do its job on Bob and it is likely to find a recount is required in SA’s ballot for the senate, an event which pollsters predict could produce another Labor senator.

… aware of Day’s financial interest …

If Culleton abstains from voting as promised, Labor need only two crossbench votes to defeat government legislation. Whilst Turnbull maintains that the crossbench may yet prove biddable, news that the government was aware of Day’s financial interest in his Adelaide office at least since before the election will make it hard to dispel the suspicion that his government was too keen on Day’s vote to query its legality. Even harder to evade is the impression that its high-handed arrogance has caused the born-to-rule party to become unstuck.

The government went to some expense, it seems, to buy Day’s vote. The revelation that in November 2015 the Coalition donated two million dollars to Adelaide’s North East Vocational College knowing that Day was a director and a former chairman of 10 years’ standing has been met with strenuous denial from government despite the existence of photographs showing Simon Birmingham visiting the college with Day six months earlier.

When the going gets tough the tough become ludicrous, at least according to Bill Shorten who has dismissed as very silly indeed Peter “Nutso” Dutton’s desperate attempt to up his government’s cruelty to asylum-seekers to divert attention from its self-inflicted chaos.

Is it legal? Immigration Minister Peter Dutton talks all over Fran Kelly Monday when she dares to question the government’s proposal to banish forever those being tortured on Nauru and Manus Island. It’s his latest ploy in a plan to wedge Labor on immigration and paint it as soft on border protection. Thomas Albrecht, the United Nations refugee agency’s regional representative says the bill appears to breach Article 31 of the Refugee Convention, which prohibits refugees being penalised for seeking protection in an irregular manner.

The Attorney-General’s department has given its assurance that the proposed bill is constitutional and it meets our international obligations, splutters Dutton. Enough said. He brushes the ABC aside lightly as befits a minister whose beef is that the public broadcaster is packed with lefties and has a jihad against Immigration. The paranoid border protector explains to mate Ray Hadley, the ABC is part of a conspiracy. “Sometimes, particularly through some of the left wing media outlets, Border Force gets a pretty rough time.”

Imagine all the good news stories Aunty could be reporting that Immigration has to tell about indefinite detention, self-harm on Nauru or the physical and sexual abuse of those in its care. No wonder Dutton is forced to set up Border Force podcasts to get out the positive accounts, insights and reflections about feeling trapped forever on an island hell-hole.

… misleading of parliament …

Article 31 of the United Nations’ 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees states that signatories “shall not impose penalties, on account of their illegal entry or presence, on refugees”.
Dutton is on thin ice. His claim that due diligence has been done by the Attorney-General is unfortunate after Brandis’ false claim about his government’s citizen-stripping bill having been vetted or his recent misleading of parliament that the solicitor general had consented to becoming a dog on the Attorney-General’s leash.

The act of calculated cruelty is the latest in a series of desperate attempts by a faction-ridden Turnbull government to divert attention from its bungling incompetence and its delusion that it is above the law. Is it so desperate to appease its xenophobic right wing and to arrest its plummeting popularity that it will stoop to persecute the weakest and most wounded?

It is unconscionably inhumane to further crush the spirits of those already suffering the torture of indefinite detention, deprivation and brutality. Is this a bizarrely perverse response to the UN’s report on Manus and the endemic suffering and institutionalised abuse exposed by the reports leaked by the Guardian Australia earlier this year.

Some call it folly. Bernard Keane and others point out that as an attempt to wedge Labor it will fail. The Australian electorate no longer trusts the government much more than the opposition on asylum-seekers. Polls now indicate at best a two point advantage over Labor.

What is clear is that the proposed bill reflects the moral bankruptcy of a Coalition conflicted internally; irreparably divided if not crippled by its capture by its conservative rump, a government of bungling incompetence and self-inflicted injury. Its backers call the tune on energy and the environment, a coherent if shameless capitulation to big mining, big business, big banking. Yet its latest move reveals a heart of darkness.

In the administration or systematised wilful neglect of asylum seekers and refugees on Nauru and Manus, torture has become our government’s policy. Is it now so desperate to boost its stakes that it is prepared to stoop to random acts of arbitrary and gratuitous cruelty?

*David Tyler (AKA Urban Wronski) was born in England, raised in New Zealand and an Australian resident since 1979. Urban Wronski grew up conflicted about his own national identity and continues to be deeply mistrustful of all nationalism, chauvinism, flags, politicians and everything else which divides and obscures our common humanity. He has always been enchanted by nature and by the extraordinary brilliance of ordinary men and women and the genius, the power and the poetry that is their vernacular. Wronski is now a fulltime freelance writer who lives with his partner and editor Shay and their chooks, near the Grampians in rural Victoria and he counts himself the luckiest man alive. A former teacher of all ages and stages, from Tertiary to Primary, for nearly forty years, he enjoyed contesting the corporatisation of schooling to follow his own natural instinct for undifferentiated affection, approval and compassion for the young.

Mercury: Colbeck calls for Liberal unity

ABC: Colbeck calls for Liberal Party unity, Duniam insists the ‘house is in order’

ABC: Tasmanian Liberals vote to ditch ‘disgusting, belligerent’ Safe Schools program

Guardian: As climate disaster looms, Malcolm Turnbull needs to stop appeasing and start leading

Author Credits: [show_post_categories parent="no" parentcategory="writers" show = "category" hyperlink="yes"]


  1. Wining Pom

    November 23, 2016 at 7:38 pm

    The biggest moron is the person who dreamed up the backpacker tax. Just tax them like everyone else.

  2. Harry Creamer

    November 23, 2016 at 7:03 pm

    Backpacker Tax.

    It’s hard to know who is the greater moron, Bill Shorten or Jackie Lambie.

  3. PLB

    November 7, 2016 at 3:42 pm

    Labors Lies about Medicare Blinded Voters to …
    Correct, that’s the bit most of your commentators will bypass to have their hit…

  4. Chris

    November 7, 2016 at 11:50 am

    There is a upper member (upstairs) who ran a legal practice for years and did not put time sheets in either.
    Colebeck of the chainsaw club, ought to come out and say who demoted him to the unwinning spot on the Senate ticket, in other words he dida Barnett on him and then it became obvious that his “replacement” came from Wee Willy’s office and from that the calls for unity and a wider appeal to the voters will not eventuate, even if the Turncow Fizza pleads for sanity.
    To top it all the Reverend (lets alter the Safe Schools programme) Whiter than snow gets on the executive with a hand gesture to any real Liberals left.
    The Empire Still Strikes and expands in the Right wing kingdom of Abetzland.
    Ericha nominates connection to the copper in Queenstown, just bore a hole and connect to the mine and there is the newest Fraudband in the land.


  5. Leveller

    November 6, 2016 at 7:51 pm

    How can it be that one of the ALP’s longest serving State MP’s for LYONS doesn’t go to his office and work every day when he is not in Parliament? This has been going on for the last few year’s while the MP is busy running his winery. Is this Claiming Public Monies under False Pretences?, Misuse of Public Monies or Misappropriation of Public Monies? surely this is not legal?. It would seem the “age of Politician’s entitlement’s” is not over for some…

  6. TGC

    November 6, 2016 at 12:46 pm

    “Liberal stooge Bob Day” a slight counter to the Labor stooges with the heading ‘Greens’

  7. Luigi Brown

    November 6, 2016 at 12:04 pm

    The fact that one senior Liberal party member – Colbeck – thinks there’s a real problem, while another – Duniam – thinks it’s all hunky-dory, is the perfect exemplar of their problem.

    There’s another election just around the corner, boys. Wakey, wakey!

  8. mark h

    November 6, 2016 at 11:35 am

    #1 G’day phill, on the wind subject you may find this interesting.


  9. john hayward

    November 6, 2016 at 10:58 am

    People smugglers, at least the managerial rung of the industry, are the very incarnation of Lib Party values – rapacious freebooters carrying no ethical cargo. Small wonder there is so little clamour from their Aussie soul mates for them to be brought to justice.

    Refugees, by contrast, are here, are powerless, are far more numerous, and are distinct from the Aussie ethnic average. This makes them the ideal bait for the xenophobes who comprise a goodly portion of Coalition constituents.

    Having already adopted Donald’s ad hoc approach to legislation, Malcolm could not be unaware of the success achieved by Trump’s brain-free appeal to the collective id.

    John Hayward

  10. Keith Antonysen

    November 6, 2016 at 10:57 am

    While Abbott was PM there had been much sneaky business in relation to Medicare. It would appear that not much has changed under Turnbull:


    Quote of first paragraph:

    “The sickest Australians to be denied proper medical attention according to the Australian Medical Association (AMA). This will impact on patients with cancer, diabetes and other serious illnesses.
    The government is to impose a maximum of $1795 of GP care for a year of Medicare funding. Just five extra visits to the doctor if these people need medical attention for issues aside from their chronic illness The news was released on 4 November.”

    People with chronic conditions do not have robust health and are more likely to effected by illness not closely related to their condition.

  11. Wining Pom

    November 6, 2016 at 9:49 am

    Good wrap up there U.W.

    If the assault on asylum seekers does not wedge Labor, what will the Coalition think of next?

    I think more boat people are needed to make up for the backpacker shortfall. That tax was another completely ridiculous idea.

    Rob Sitch must be warming his keyboard up.

  12. phill Parsons

    November 6, 2016 at 9:02 am

    Days building in Adelaide, , the one where he benefited from the rent of his office by the Commonwealth, was described on Insiders as nutter HQ.

    According to David Marr it also contains the offices of fringe organizations. It’s a wonder the Wind Commissioner was not located there. I suppose thta Office will remain until Lleyonhelm goes from the Senate or it becomes so ridiculous that even he agrees to end it.

    The Cullerton clown is without a leg to stand on, so we may see 100% of the cross bench needed to pass unpopular and awful legislation through the Senate. But most likely he will be replaced by his brother, who made it possible for the Electoral Commission to group Family First on the ballot paper.

    Will the brother be as big a blowhard?.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To Top